Can IVF acupuncture improve live birth rates, aka take home babies?

Despite 20 years of vigorous IVF research, we still are trying to find an answer. When you browse our blog you will read many IVF studies where acupuncture group had higher numbers of pregnancies or live births. But there are a few studies that show no effect on pregnancy rates. However, they often have other benefits, like improved embryo quality or better blood flow in the uterus or reduced stress. All in all, IVF acupuncture research may seem a bit hard to draw clear conclusions.

If you think that evidence is a bit confusing, here is a perfect study to clear things up.

Our ABORM colleague Lee Hullender Rubin in December 2019 published an article diving deep into current IVF acupuncture situation. She took two latest and most rigorous systematic reviews and meta-analysis; picked them apart and came up with a pretty neat overview.

Here you have it, a summary on what acupuncture can do during your next IVF, according to data of 1980 women.

The summary of the current evidence on how acupuncture influences IVF outcomes

1. Compared to no treatment, acupuncture increases

  • Clinical pregnancy rate by 28%–32%
  • Ongoing pregnancy rate by 42%
  • Live birth rate by 30%.

 

2. The efficacy of is still unclear and confounded by the need for adequate, inert control.

IVF acupuncture efficacy can be proven only when this natural therapy does better than a sham. However, we don’t have a sham that is inert, without any effect. As a result, we end up comparing acupuncture to some other form of acupuncture. Most commonly used shams are penetrating or nonpenetrating needles inserted on or off acupoints. Sham needles often mix up the results and lead to erroneous rejection of this natural therapy.

 

3. Acupuncture more effective for increasing live births:

  • In patients with previously failed cycles
  • IVF clinics with a baseline pregnancy rate <32% (in other words, most IVF clinics in NZ).

 

4. Factors that can improve the outcomes are:

  • More acupuncture treatments,
  • Treatment focused before and on the day of embryo transfer
  • Using a modified Paulus protocol on the day of embryo transfer

 

Point of Influence?

Lee E. Hullender Rubin, DAOM, MS, LAc, FABORM

Augmenting in vitro fertilization (IVF) with acupuncture is a popular adjuvant therapy in the United States, but its influence on IVF birth outcomes remains controversial.

Recent meta-analyses found acupuncture is effective to increase the risk of live births by 30% when it was compared with no treatment in nine trials of 1,980 women.

The efficacy of acupuncture is unclear, however, and confounded by the need for adequate, inert control. This natural therapy does not increase the risk of miscarriage. Additionally, it was 42% more effective to increase live births when women had previously failed a cycle, and the baseline pregnancy rate continues to mediate acupuncture’s effects.

The characteristics of treatment more favourable to improving birth outcomes included more treatments, timing treatments in the period before and on the day of embryo transfer (ET), and using a modified Paulus protocol on the day of ET.

These findings should inform the dosage, timing, and components of this therapy and type of comparator in future trials investigating the effects of acupuncture on IVF outcomes.